Hospice Compliance Discussed by Experienced Nationwide Medicare Attorneys
The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) is one of many federal agencies tasked with enforcing federal Medicare regulations, including hospice compliance. The Office of Inspector General (OIG) is HHS’s primary enforcement arm and is the largest inspector general’s office in the federal government. According to OIG’s website, it consists of approximately 1,600 [employees] dedicated to combating fraud, waste, and abuse and to improving the efficiency of HHS programs, including Medicare. In fact, [a] majority of OIG’s resources go toward the oversight of Medicare and Medicaid.
For several years, hospices have been among OIG’s top priorities with regard to Medicare enforcement and hospice compliance. Based upon the OIG’s recent report, Hospices Should Improve their Election Statements and Certifications of Terminal Illnesses, (the OIG Hospice Report) it appears that this is unlikely to change anytime soon.
More Than 33 Percent of Hospice Stays Raise Medicare Compliance Concerns
The 28-page OIG Hospice Report identifies two primary deficiencies in hospice compliance. The first has to do with election statements. According to the OIG Hospice Report, the OIG identified election statement deficiencies in more than one-third of all general inpatient care stays analyzed for purposes of the report. These deficiencies largely had to do with failing to sign statements stating that either: (i) the beneficiary was waiving certain Medicare benefits by electing hospice care, or (ii) the hospice care was palliative rather than curative in nature.
The second major deficiency was in the area of physician certifications. According to the OIG Hospice Report, 14 percent of all general inpatient care stays involved a missing, inadequate, or fraudulent physician certification. In particular, the report notes deficiencies including:
[N]ot meet[ing] requirements such as composing a narrative when certifying that the beneficiary was terminally ill and appear[ing] to have limited involvement in determining that the beneficiary was appropriate for hospice care.
Hospice Owners Are Being Targeted for Federal Civil and Criminal Prosecutions
With billions of Medicare dollars going to hospices every year, OIG is committed to enforcing Medicare’s requirements for reimbursement of hospice care services. Failure to obtain a valid election statement and use of invalid or fraudulent physician certifications are key enforcement targets, as hospice’s noncompliance with these requirements not only results in waste of Medicare resources but can lead to inadequate or inappropriate patient care, as well.
In recent years, some of OIG’s civil and criminal enforcement cases against hospices and hospice owners have included:
A three-year prison sentence and $1.1 million restitution penalty for a hospice owner who submitted fraudulent Medicare claims for patients who were not suited to hospice care and were not aware they were receiving hospice services.
A 14-year prison sentence and $16.2 million restitution penalty for a hospice owner who altered patient records and paid healthcare professionals to refer patients even though they were not suited for hospice care.
A potential 10-year prison sentence in an ongoing case where a hospice’s Chief Operating Officer has admitted to causing staff members to put non-qualifying patients in hospice care.
As you can see, the potential consequences of Medicare fraud in the hospice setting are severe. While the vast majority of hospices that violate Medicare’s requirements do so inadvertently, this often is not enough to avoid coming into the crosshairs of OIG.
This is Why You Are in Good Hands
Nick has been there since the beginning. Throughout this experience he has had made me feel like my case is his most important. He excels in his area of law and I would not hesitate to recommend him to anyone that needs assistance. I am honored to have had him help me through this period.read more
Quick response, very knowledgeable, passionate, with a caring team with real experiencewith the same federal agencies that I was corresponding with (Roger Bach!) thus making all the legal concerns understandable. I would recommend to any other health care professional or would use Nick Oberheiden again if ever needed. Thank you!read more
I am compelled to recommend Nick Oberheiden after dealing with many blood thirsty attorneys. Nick was extremely responsive, knowledgeable, and trustworthy. His expertise and relationships in the realm of federal healthcare is great. I wish I would have called him sooner. If you are facing a federal investigation or suit, make Nick the first call you make. He really cares and is looking out for his clients best interest. His expertise has allowed my situation that seemed so daunting to be very manageable.read more
I found myself in an unfortunate situation with the federal government. I hired Nick Oberheiden as my attorney and it has been a life saving decision. His expertise and knowledge along with his commitment is superior and of utmost importance in federal cases. Nick has kept his word throughout this stressful process and helped me receive the best possible outcome. You will not regret hiring Nick and his law firm to defend you!!!read more
Over the past decade I have plenty of experience with health care and federal attorneys. The one that has stood by far above and beyond the most intelligent, thoughtful, straight-forward, and strategic in defense and actions has been Nick Oberheiden. Nick has achieved results that others claim they could not. He has taken on circumstances that felt as if not winnable, and worked to create a positive outcome. Nick has become a rock and support person through my troubling time and a beacon of hope and action that things will come out in the best possible manner. There is no attorney that I could support more then Dr. Oberheiden.read more
Dr Nick Oberheiden is a truly excellent attorney in every way! He’s knowledgeable and responds to all phone calls and emails swiftly. He is concise, and puts information in understandable terms. He is happy to explain and clarify any confusing matters or material. He will put your mind at ease immediately. For me, it was like a superhero was protecting and helping me through what was one of the most stressful situations of my professional life! Nick is worth every single bit of the five star rating from me, and from other clients who have given him five star reviews as well!read more
We needed legal service and advise, Nick Oberheiden made a bad situation better. Prompt service, responded to email , and phone calls, addressed the problem professionally and on time. Would highly recomend them.
I have conferred and worked with Nick on several healthcare fraud defense cases, representing doctors, laboratory/pharmacy owners, durable medical equipment providers and marketing companies all investigated by the U.S. Department of Justice. Nick's level of expertise when it comes to the intricacies of medicare billing, operational regulations and corporate structure is unmatched. His experience and knowledge, combined with his high-level contacts within the Department of Justice, nationwide, make him an invaluable resource to anyone who finds themselves being investigated or audited by the Government. Nick is easy to communicate with, and goes above and beyond to make himself available to his clients and colleagues in their time of need.read more
From the moment we walked into Nick’s office, he made us feel safe and secure. Nick exemplifies kindness and compassion for his clients, qualities that I have found rare with attorneys. Nicks passion and expertise in Healthcare and Law are unrivaled.I strongly encourage and recommend others to use Nick. Professionally, Nick is a Genius!read more
As a former supervising investigator with a large New York State agency investigating health care fraud, I have conferred with many defense attorneys over my thirty-year career. I can honestly say that I was not impressed with many of them, that is, until I met Dr. Nick Oberheiden. Not only is he an exceptional attorney, who provides his clients with expert strategic legal guidance, he is highly regarded for his extraordinary character and integrity. Nick is extremely ethical and always has his clients' best interests at heart. Today, I am proud, honored and privileged to work with Nick in assisting him with his clients' needs, whether it is to determine if they have any criminal liability or to proactively establish a compliance program to prevent them from falling victim to any government audit/investigation. Nick works very efficiently - saving his clients time and money. So, if you are looking for an attorney to represent you or to offer you expert guidance, don't hesitate and contact Dr. Nick Oberheiden. You'll be glad you did!read more
I was a federal agent for over 30 years and have worked with many of the most successful DOJ and DoD attorneys. Dr. Oberheiden leads a team made up of the best former Federal, State, local attorneys and investigators that can quickly assess any type of federal legal matter. The collective knowledge and experience of Dr. Oberheiden and his "Dream Team" have yielded successful outcomes in a significant number of federal legal matters which have benefited his clients time and time again! He and his team are determined to work each case to anticipate a prosecutor's case strategy and identity weaknesses in that strategy. Dr. Oberheiden is a relentless legal strategist that has earned him his favorable reputation among the legal community nationwide! If you want a reliable and results-oriented lawyer working for you, Oberheiden P.C. has my highest recommendation and confidence!read more
During the past year, i had the privilege to work alongside Dr. Nick Oberheiden as a team-member defending the owners of a specialty pharmacy being investigated by the HHS-OIG and the USDOJ. Thanks to Nick's leadership, knowledge and expertise, "Team Oberheiden" earned the pharmacy and its owners exoneration from criminal and civil penalties. Case closed!read more
Excellent lawyer! I have been very happy with his legal services and highly recommend Dr. Nick Oberheiden.
Nick was extremely professional, polite, helpful, and friendly. He put my friend at ease and made us feel welcome to be with her. He answered our questions even though we were just there for support. Would definitely recommend him to anyone and would use myself if ever needed.read more
Nick is not smart, he is BRILLIANT! He knows the proceedings of the court extremely well and is a genius when working with prosecutors and judges!He is extremely hard working, and although I knew he was working on multiple cases, every time we dealt with mine, he made me feel that my case is the most important to him. I will most certainly not be where I am, had it not been for Nick. I had worked with a couple of lawyers before Nick came so highly recommended to me, and I can tell you that he simply light years above them. Nick bats for the big leagues!!read more
Lorraine Emma De Blanche
I am a retired FBI Special Agent, who worked extensively with many attorneys. I find Dr. Oberheiden ti be very knowledgeable of the healthcare issues. He has a vast knowledge of all federal violations. He is very conscientious about the benefits of his clients. I saw him working around the continent of North America to assist his clients. One of the great traits of the Oberheiden Law Firm, is that he tackles the allegations long before they reach the court stage. His capable staff is also very qualified and assist all clients as if they are the only client in their firm. I strongly recommend the Oberheiden Law Firm to anyone who has a federal case.read more
Nick is extremely professional and knows what he is doing. He is also very kind as a person (unless he is in court!) I would recommend him to just about anyone if they need an amazing lawyer that is top notch and would frankly be scary to face in the court room. He will always do a great job representing his clients. Thank you very much.read more
Nick is the absolute top expert in any federal case
Smart. Smarter. Nick.As a healthcare executive, I once ran into a litigation issue. I hired Nick and, literally, before I knew it the case was resolved in my favor. Nick has an incredible presence and every lawyer in the room knows that Nick will do exactly what he says. It was a mesmerizing experience to see Nick in action! Very calm and determined, Nick is the absolute top litigator.read more
Whitney Bryant Milam
Nick has been a friend and trusted advisor for almost 10 years. As anyone just looking at his bio can tell, Nick is an outstanding attorney in highest demand across the country. All healthcare providers should hire attorney Nick Oberheiden!! You will not be disappointed.read more
Dr. Oberheiden has served as council and represented our company on several occasions, even during depositions, contract reviews and providing invaluable advice on multiple occasions that transpired into multilevel success in our business. He and his teams knowledge of both local, state and federal statues, accompanied by their areas of expertise law regarding best asset protection, estate planning and wealth management solutions have provided both professional and personal growth for my companies, safeguarding them and protection my family’s name and legacy. I would recommend this firm and Dr. Nick Oberheiden without hesitation. I have no doubt that you will experience success with his council.read more
I have worked with Nick Oberheiden for over ten years on various litigation matters in and around New York City. Nick is an accomplished and seasoned lawyer and litigator---efficient, reliable, practical and, at the same time, highly academic. Nick will take the time necessary to understand a client's short- and long-term goals, and tailor his representation and advice to work toward and achieve those ends. Nick is a zealous advocate for his client, and will never sacrifice his client's interests for a quick or easy resolution to a case. At the end of the day, Nick is a great person to know if you or your business is in need of a top litigator or defense attorney.read more
When I was faced with one of the most terrifying and unexpected situations in my life, I called Dr. Oberheiden. I had vetted other attorneys and came right back to him. His knowledge, expertise, and reassuring presence made the decision easy. Throughout my case, his level of communication was what I needed and expected. He constantly updated me on the status and progress of my case and was able to “talk me off the ledge” when the stress of it all would set in. He is simply the best of the best...there’s not a question about it.read more
Nick is a superb lawyer with exceptional skills and a formidable personality. Nick works harder, he thinks smarter, and he delivers faster than any lawyer you will ever find. Good, better, Nick!
1st class service. Atty. Iberheiden and Atty. Lynette Byrd were always available for us during the whole process of our Home Health Audit. Thank you so much!
I am a healthcare compliance consultant with almost 25 years of experience. The one advice I have for anyone seeking a lawyer with unbeatable healthcare law experience is to hire attorney Nick Oberheiden. For the past 8 years, I have worked with Nick on a variety of healthcare matters—from DEA compliance to DOL supervisory rules to setting up PT and pain management clinics. I have never once seen a client not being 100% intrigued by Nick’s proven expertise in the field of healthcare structuring and compliance.Dr. S.T.read more
Nick Oberheiden is a spectacular lawyer, a true life saver. Nick is simply the very best!
Nick Oberheiden is the absolute best federal litigation attorney. Nick gives you the immediate comfort of feeling 100% protected. He is polite, respectful— and extremely compelling. His legal strategy turned out to be brilliant.
Great firm, with a great firm record of experienced healthcare and litigation attorneys.
In Focus: The Hospice Election Statement and Physician Certification Requirements
What is an Election Statement?
In order to receive hospice care that is eligible for Medicare, the patient (or beneficiary) must sign an “election statement” prepared by the hospice. This election statement must contain certain acknowledgements, including:
That the patient has been provided with complete and accurate information regarding the palliative (rather than curative) nature of hospice care; and,
That the patient is waiving his or her right to Medicare coverage for treatment not provided or arranged for by the patient’s chosen hospice services provider.
What Are Hospices Obligations Regarding Election Statements?
Hospices must obtain Medicare-compliant election statements from all beneficiaries prior to commencing palliative care, this is a crucial part of hospice compliance. If a beneficiary chooses to revoke his or her election by providing a signed statement, the hospice must respect the beneficiary’s decision.
What is a Physician Certification?
In addition to supplying an election statement, in order to qualify for Medicare-reimbursed hospice care, a patient must also receive a physician certification stating that (i) the patient is terminally ill, and (ii) the patient’s life expectancy is six months or less. The physician certification must include a narrative explaining the physician’s clinical findings, which cannot include standardized language or be based on a check-the-box form. The physician must also attest that he or she prepared the narrative personally based on a physical examination or a review of the patient’s clinical record.
What Are Hospices Obligations Regarding Physician Certifications?
Hospices must obtain a Medicare-compliant physician certification for each patient. Hospices cannot “recruit” patients for hospice care and they cannot compensate doctors for certifying patients who do not meet the standards for Medicare-reimbursed hospice services. Hospices are also prohibited from falsifying physician statements; and, while hospices can provide care for patients who live longer than six months, they cannot rely on fraudulently prepared certifications in order to provide treatment to non-terminally-ill patients.
Key Statistics from the OIG Hospice Report
Getting further into the details of the OIG Hospice Report, the OIG identified numerous specific deficiencies with election statements and physician certifications some of which (as you might expect) were more common than others. Here are some of the most noteworthy statistics:
Election Statements: Key Statistics Leading to Enhanced OIG Enforcement
Key statistics regarding inadequate and fraudulent patient election statements include:
19 PercentThe amount of election statements failing to specify that the patient was electing Medicare hospice benefits. According to the OIG Hospice Report: It is important for beneficiaries to know which benefit they are receiving, especially because eligibility criteria and election periods in some State Medicaid programs differ from those in Medicare, and private health insurance may cover hospice care very differently than Medicare.
12 PercentThe amount of election statements failing to state that the patient acknowledged he or she was waiving certain Medicare benefits by electing hospice care, or else containing an inaccurate waiver of benefits. For example, some election statements stated that the beneficiary waived the right to all other benefits under the Medicare program while receiving hospice benefits… [but a] beneficiary who elects hospice care retains rights to Medicare payment for services to treat conditions unrelated to the terminal illness.
9 PercentThe amount of election statements that lacked required information about the nature of palliative care. Nearly one in 10 patients did not receive adequate disclosures regarding the fact that hospice services involve, patient- and family-centered care that optimizes the quality of life by anticipating, preventing, and treating suffering.
Physician Certifications: Key Statistics Leading to Enhanced OIG Enforcement
Key statistics regarding inadequate and fraudulent physician certifications for hospice care include:
10 Percent The amount of physician certifications that lacked a narrative entirely or only included the physician’s diagnosis of the patient’s condition. This means that the certifying physician did not explain the clinical findings that support a life expectancy for the beneficiary of 6 months or less, which in turn means that the hospice lacked the information required in order to bill for Medicare reimbursement.
5 Percent The amount of physician certifications that lacked an attestation. The OIG heavily emphasizes the attestation requirement for certifications, since, attesting that the narrative was based on an examination or record review [is an] important safeguard to ensure that certifying physicians fulfill their role and demonstrate active involvement in the certifying process.
What Can Hospices Expect in terms of Compliance for the Future?
Based on the issues identified in the OIG Hospice Report, the OIG made four recommendations to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS):
To develop and disseminate model text for election statements;
To instruct surveyors to strengthen their review of hospice election statements and physician certifications;
To educate hospices about election statement and physician certification requirements; and,
To educate hospices regarding the effects on beneficiaries resulting from revocation of elections and being discharged from hospice care.
As a result, while hospices can likely expect additional guidance with respect to these key areas of Hospice compliance for medicare, this additional guidance may also result in additional enforcement efforts. For example, hospices that fail to take advantage of the OIG’s model language and educational offerings may become primary targets for federal investigations. Hospices that make honest mistakes will likely continue to find themselves at the center of federal investigations as well, and these hospices will need skilled legal representation in order to avoid the long-term consequences that can result from garnering the attention of CMS and the OIG.
Nationwide Legal Representation for Hospices in OIG Investigations and Hospice Compliance | Oberheiden, P.C.
With offices around the country, the Oberheiden, P.C. is a law firm comprised of former federal fraud prosecutors and experienced healthcare fraud defense attorneys. If you or your hospice has been contacted by HHS, OIG, CMS, or any other federal agency regarding a potential Medicare billing issue, it is important that you speak with a lawyer as soon as possible. What initially appears to be a routine inquiry can quickly lead to a federal investigation. For a free and confidential consultation, call (888) 705-5902 or contact us online today.